When I realized I hadn’t done this trio for marry, date, or dump yet I palmed my face. It is so obvious! It is so fun! I am so excited to read about who you choose in the comments. So have at it!
Marry, Date or Dump: Aragorn, Legolas, & Gimli
Reader, Writer, & Writing Teacher
Alison Doherty 
Easiest one ever – Marry Aragorn, Date Legolas, Dump Gimli –
Yeah, I wasn’t sure if I should pick Gimli as the third.
Ditto! And you get to be queen!
You get to be queen with both Aragorn and Legolas…so actually there is a bit more consideration necessary.
I vote with Martha!
Me too! This is definitely what I would do. I’m expecting there might be a few Legolas fans out there though.
I would marry Legolas .
I would date Aragorn, I might date Gimli too for some precious stones ( if you did not think about this too, then why on earth did you even mention him? :)) Then I would dump them both. Aragorn is too melancholic to marry.
Such a good call about the jewels!
Oh, I would also date Eomer and Boromir, but you had to add Gimli 🙂
Eomer was the other person I was considering.
Great choice! As it says on my reblog, I’d marry Aragorn, date Legolas and dump Gimli!
Yea if the other two weren’t quiet so spectacular – I could give book Gimli not movie Gimli some love.
Marry Legolas-calm is good when it comes with elven advantages. Dump Aragorn-he drags his feet, broods, and would never feel right about putting me first. Date Gimli-it’d be a good time.
If Eomer were in here I’d marry him and date Legolas though, ’cause while I enjoy elven beauty and all, it’d get very hard to be married to that while I age and lose faculties. Same goes for Faramir. If Boromir I’d still marry Eomer, Faramir, or Legolas, but date him instead of Gimli, as he would be both a good time and hot. So many permutations!
I would Marry Legolas because he is awesome. Also, a lot of you said if you marry Aragon you get to be Queen, but Legolas is going to be king once his father either dies or gives up the throne. Also, he is calm, and I really love the elves and their languages and such. The age difference could prove to be a problem though.
I would date Aragorn since, first of, I hate living underground, and secondly, Aragorn is more sensitive and I would prefer him over Gimli. He can be a bit brooding, but Gimli always struck me as kind of naive and a bit selfish.
I don’t think Legolas’s father will ever give up the throne. I mean, why should he?
I would definitely marry Aragorn, because he is caring and has a lot of battle experience so he could protect me. I would date Legolas, because he’s cute, and I’d dump Gimli because he is ugly.